What we do and what it costs.
Consignment
What's included.
We list your eligible cards on Fanatics Collect as a top-tier seller, prep each card for grading, manage the listing, track the sale, and pay you out with an itemized statement when the card sells.
Eligibility.
Cards with a declared raw value of $250 or more. Sports, Pokemon, and other TCG cards — raw and already-graded slabs both qualify; raw cards are submitted to PSA, BGS, or CGC before listing. We also take authenticated memorabilia — signed gloves, balls, jerseys — reviewed case-by-case.
Pricing.
A flat 5% commission on the hammer price for auction sales — you keep 95%. Buy It Now sales carry a 15% commission on net proceeds (the sale price less the marketplace seller fee). We don't take a cut until your card sells.
What you pay up front.
One thing: the inbound FedEx label after we've approved your card. Every other fee comes out of the sale — grading included. We front the grading fee and recover it at payout.
What we cover.
Outbound shipping to Fanatics. Always.
Grading-prep cleaning
What's included.
A careful surface clean so your card presents its best on the grader's desk — and the grade reflects the card, not the dust on it. Wipe, debris removal, gentle polish on holo foil scratches. No structural manipulation.
Available as.
A per-card add-on within a consignment submission. We don't do cleaning-only jobs separate from consignment.
Pricing.
Free. Grading prep is included at no charge on any card where you select it.
Grading submission management
What's included.
All raw consigned cards are routed through PSA, BGS, or CGC for authentication and grading before listing. Tell us your preferred grader — or ask us to advise — and we route based on the card's value and condition. We submit, track turnaround, and enter results into your portal when they come back.
Pricing.
We front the grading fee at the grader's rate — confirmed with you before submission — and recover it at payout.
Pricing reference
| Item | Rate | Who pays | When |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consignment commission | Flat 5% of hammer (auction) · 15% of net proceeds (Buy It Now) | You (deducted at payout) | At payout |
| Grading prep (consignment add-on) | $0 — included when selected | No one — it's free | — |
| Inbound shipping (you → us) | Your declared value, at FedEx rate | You | After we approve your cards |
| Outbound shipping (us → Fanatics) | $0 | We cover it | — |
| Grading fees (PSA / BGS / CGC) | Fronted by Broly's — recovered at payout | You (deducted at payout) | At payout |