Fanatics Collect Consignment
Higher prices.
Lower fees.
None of the hassle.
Cards sell for more on Fanatics Collect than on eBay or at shows — and on Fanatics, the buyer pays the auction fees, not you. We list yours as a top-tier Fanatics Collect seller, prep each card for grading, and only get paid when one sells. Your only upfront cost is shipping to us.
Consignment
We list eligible cards on Fanatics Collect on your behalf. Tiered commission on the hammer price — 10% up to $999, 8% from $1,000–$2,999, 6% at $3,000+. Minimum card value $250.
Cleaning
Grading prep, done right. A careful surface clean so your card presents its best on the grader's desk — and the grade reflects the card, not the dust on it. Wipe, debris removal, gentle polish on holo foil scratches. Nothing structural. $25 per card, flat.
All raw cards are submitted to PSA, BGS, or CGC before listing. We front every grading fee — it comes out of your sale at payout, never out of your pocket.
The Fanatics access.
Broly's is a top-tier seller on Fanatics Collect — the marketplace where cards sell for more than eBay or the show floor. Outbound shipping to the auction is fully insured and entirely on us, every item, every time. One less cost between you and your payout.
The paper trail.
Every submission is documented end to end. Sealed package photographed on arrival. Each card photographed individually before any work begins — that intake shot is your before. Work results photographed when the bench is done. Every status change is timestamped and on the record.
Submit.
Create an account, fill out the card details, upload photos from your phone.
Sign + pay.
Once we approve your card, sign the consignment agreement and pay the inbound FedEx label. Every other fee comes out of the sale.
Ship.
Drop the package at FedEx — or hand it to us in person if you're local to Myrtle Beach. We photograph the sealed package the moment it arrives.
Work.
Clean, conserve, and submit for grading — you see every step.
List, sell, payout.
Your card goes live on Fanatics. When it sells, you get an itemized statement and your share.
| Item | Rate |
|---|---|
| Consignment commission | Tiered on the hammer price: 10% up to $999, 8% $1,000–$2,999, 6% $3,000+ |
| Cleaning (consignment add-on) | $25 per card |
| Inbound shipping (you to us) | Your choice of declared value, FedEx rate |
| Outbound shipping (us to Fanatics) | We cover it |
| Grading fees | Fronted by Broly's — recovered from your sale at payout |